Round vs. Elongated Commode Seats: Which Is Best for You?

Introduction

When it comes to upgrading your bathroom, most people don’t give much thought to the shape of their commode seat. However, choosing between a round and an elongated seat can significantly impact your comfort, aesthetics, and even hygiene. Whether you’re renovating your bathroom or simply replacing your toilet seat, this guide will help you understand the key differences between round and elongated commode seats to help you make the best choice.

The Basics of Commode Seat Shapes

When you first look at commode seats, they may all seem the same. But take a closer look, and you’ll notice that they generally come in two main shapes: round and elongated. Understanding these two shapes can make all the difference when deciding which one suits your bathroom best.

Understanding Round Seats

Round commode seats are generally shorter and more compact. These seats have been the standard for many years and are still commonly found in older homes or smaller bathrooms. Round seats typically measure about 16.5 inches from the mounting holes to the front of the seat.

What Makes Elongated Seats Different?

Elongated commode seats, on the other hand, are about 18.5 inches long and offer a more oval shape. These seats are newer in design and are becoming more popular in modern bathrooms due to their sleek look and added comfort.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

Bathroom Size and Space Constraints

One of the first things to consider is the amount of space in your bathroom. If you have a smaller bathroom, a round seat might be the better option as it takes up less space. Elongated seats, while more comfortable, require more room, so they may not be ideal for tight spaces.

Comfort Levels and Ergonomics

Comfort is another crucial factor. Elongated seats are generally considered more comfortable because of their larger surface area, making them more ergonomically friendly. If comfort is your priority, an elongated seat might be the way to go.

Design Preferences and Aesthetics

Your choice between round and elongated also depends on the overall look you’re going for. Elongated seats tend to have a more modern, sleek design, while round seats offer a more traditional appearance.

The Case for Round Commode Seats

Compact and Space-Saving

Round commode seats are perfect for smaller bathrooms or guest restrooms where space is limited. Their compact design allows for better movement around the toilet, which is essential in tight quarters.

Budget-Friendly Option

If you’re looking for a cost-effective solution, round seats tend to be less expensive than their elongated counterparts. They offer all the basic features without the higher price tag.

Traditional Look

For those who prefer a more classic bathroom aesthetic, round seats offer a timeless look that fits well with traditional bathroom designs.

The Case for Elongated Commode Seats

Superior Comfort and Ergonomics

Elongated seats offer a greater surface area, making them more comfortable for prolonged use. The ergonomic design provides better support, especially for adults and people with mobility issues.

Modern Aesthetics

If you’re aiming for a sleek and modern bathroom, an elongated seat might be the better choice. Its longer, oval shape complements contemporary designs.

Easier to Clean

Elongated seats generally have a larger opening, which makes them easier to clean. This can be a significant advantage when it comes to maintaining bathroom hygiene.

Installation and Compatibility

Compatibility with Different Toilet Bowls

Both round and elongated commode seats are compatible with specific types of toilet bowls. Before purchasing, make sure to measure your toilet and choose the seat that fits best.

Installation Process for Both Types

The installation process is straightforward for both round and elongated seats. It usually involves unscrewing the old seat and attaching the new one using the provided bolts.

Cost Differences Between Round and Elongated Seats

Price Ranges for Round Seats

Round seats are generally more affordable, with prices ranging from £20 to £50 depending on the brand and features.

Price Ranges for Elongated Seats

Elongated seats are a bit pricier, often ranging from £30 to £100. However, the added comfort and modern design can make them worth the extra investment.

Durability and Longevity

Material Options for Both Seat Types

Both round and elongated seats come in a variety of materials, including plastic, wood, and cushioned vinyl. The choice of material will affect the seat’s durability.

Which Shape Lasts Longer?

In terms of longevity, both seat types can last equally long, provided they are made from quality materials and properly maintained.

Special Features to Look For

Soft-Close Technology

Both round and elongated seats now come with soft-close technology, which prevents the seat from slamming shut. This feature is ideal for families or shared bathrooms.

Heated and Padded Seats

For those cold winter mornings, you might want to consider a heated or padded seat, available in both shapes for extra comfort.

Bidet-Integrated Seats

Bidet features are becoming increasingly popular and are available in both round and elongated designs, making your toilet experience more hygienic and convenient.

Environmental Considerations

Water Usage and Efficiency

The shape of your commode seat can also play a role in water efficiency. Elongated toilets tend to use slightly more water than round ones, though the difference is often minimal.

Sustainability of Materials

Both round and elongated seats can be made from sustainable materials, so consider eco-friendly options when making your choice.

Conclusion

Choosing between a round and elongated commode seat ultimately comes down to personal preference, comfort, and bathroom space. While elongated seats offer superior comfort and a modern look, round seats are compact and budget-friendly. Take into account the factors discussed above to ensure you pick the seat that best meets your needs.

FAQs

What is the main difference between round and elongated commode seats?
The main difference lies in their shape and size. Round seats are more compact, while elongated seats offer more surface area and comfort.
Is one type more comfortable than the other?
Yes, elongated seats are generally considered more comfortable due to their larger surface area and ergonomic design.
How do I know which seat fits my toilet?
Measure the distance from the mounting holes to the front of the toilet bowl. Round seats are about 16.5 inches, while elongated seats are around 18.5 inches.
Are elongated seats more expensive?
Typically, yes. Elongated seats tend to cost more due to their size and added comfort features.
Do both seats come with the same features?
Yes, both round and elongated seats can come with modern features like soft-close technology, heated options, and bidet integration.

Categories :

Commode